Well there you are Joy! Shall we turn this strand into a list of other daft things that have been written in horse magazines? I vote for a British Dressage team member saying categorically "you cannot free a horse's neck if they have locked it by swinging the head from side to side". Oh yes you can! (is this a panto

) - I have to do it with one of mine often when he locks his very powerful neck against me, some showjumpers (particularly the continentals) do it every time they jump, and I've seen German dressage trainers do it on telly too!
I think you're right about the contact, but that's EE for you. Some other trainers think that you should have two fistfuls of rein held like iron and drive the horse up to the contact. That trainer must be one, I saw the article and thought the same.
C.